Atomic Updates: Building the Optimal Tech Stack, Part 2 - Portfolio Reporting Tools

Following our discussion of custodians, asset managers, and asset movement solutions, we now turn our attention to a critical component of the RIA & Family Office tech stack: portfolio reporting tools. These platforms aggregate data from various sources, providing advisors and clients with a consolidated view of portfolio performance, asset allocation, and other key metrics. A well-chosen reporting tool can significantly enhance client communication, improve operational efficiency, and provide valuable insights for investment decision-making.
Unlike other areas of tech where many if not most participants offer roughly the same products and features at about the same prices, the landscape of portfolio reporting tools is wildly diverse, with options ranging from comprehensive, enterprise-level platforms to more streamlined, cost-effective solutions. In this installment, we'll delve into some of the leading players in the market, examining their strengths, weaknesses, and suitability for different types of RIA and family office practices. Let's examine five of the most popular platforms: Addepar, Orion, Envestnet Tamarac, Black Diamond, and CircleBlack.
Functionality and Features: Addepar is known for its robust capabilities in handling complex portfolios, including alternative investments and illiquid assets. It offers sophisticated performance reporting, analytics, and data aggregation features. The platform is particularly well-suited for family offices and RIAs managing high-net-worth clients with intricate financial holdings.
Pluses:
• Exceptional data aggregation across a wide range of asset classes
• Powerful performance reporting and analytics
• Handles multi-tiered ownership structures very well
• Almost infinitely customizable reporting options
• Strong security features
Minuses:
• High cost, making it less accessible for smaller RIAs
• Can be complex to implement and maintain, requiring dedicated in-house professionals with specialized training and experience, or support from external consultants
• May offer more features than are necessary for simpler practices
Cost: Addepar is generally considered one of the more expensive options, with pricing based on assets under management (AUM).
Ease of Use: While powerful, Addepar can have a steep learning curve compared to simpler platforms.
Functionality and Features: Orion offers a comprehensive suite of tools for portfolio accounting, performance reporting, rebalancing, billing, and client relationship management. It's a popular choice among RIAs due to its scalability and integration capabilities.
Pluses:
• Comprehensive functionality, covering multiple aspects of RIA operations
• Extensive integrations with other wealth tech solutions
• Strong reporting and analytics capabilities
• Scalable for growing firms
Minuses:
• Can be overwhelming for smaller firms with simpler needs, though not nearly to the same degree as Addepar
• Users have reported issues with data accuracy
• Customer support experiences can vary
Cost: Orion's pricing is usually a flat fee that correlates with AUM, with different packages available depending on the features required.
Ease of Use: Orion is generally considered user-friendly, though mastering all its features takes time.
Functionality and Features: Tamarac (part of the Envestnet platform) provides portfolio management, reporting, rebalancing, and CRM capabilities. It's designed to streamline operations and enhance client service for RIAs.
Pluses:
• Integrated platform covering multiple aspects of wealth management
• Robust rebalancing tools
• Strong client portal and communication features
• Integration with Envestnet's broader ecosystem
Minuses:
• Can be expensive, especially for smaller firms
• Integration with non-Envestnet products is limited
• Some users find the interface less intuitive than other platforms
Cost: Tamarac's pricing is generally based on AUM, with different modules available at varying costs.
Ease of Use: While comprehensive, some users find Tamarac's interface less intuitive than other options.
Functionality and Features: Black Diamond offers portfolio management, reporting, and client communication tools. It's known for its robust reporting capabilities and focus on high-net-worth clients.
Pluses:
• Strong reporting and analytics capabilities
• Customizable client portal
• Integration with Advent's other products
• Good support for complex portfolios
Minuses:
• While generally less expensive than the options above, it may still be viewed as being expensive by smaller firms
• Some users find the interface outdated compared to newer platforms
• Integration with non-Advent products is limited
Cost: Black Diamond's pricing is typically based on AUM.
Ease of Use: Some users find the interface less modern than other options.
Functionality and Features: CircleBlack is an all-in-one cloud-based wealth management platform that offers portfolio management, performance reporting, trading and rebalancing, billing, and client communication tools. It bills itself as being designed for growth-minded advisors and provides a comprehensive suite of capabilities for RIAs.
Pluses:
• Intuitive advisor dashboard with holistic view of client information
• White-label client portal and mobile app for enhanced client engagement
• Extensive integrations with 25+ WealthTech vendors and 17,000+ financial institutions
• Direct connections to 14 custodians, which while small compared to the groups above is robust at this price point
• Flexible pricing model with options for both smaller and larger firms
Minuses:
• Some advanced features like model-based rebalancing only available in the Elite plan
• Relatively new player in the market compared to more established competitors
• Requires additional integrations for comprehensive financial planning capabilities
Cost: CircleBlack is generally the lower cost alternative amongst this group and offers two pricing tiers:
• Basic: Starting at $500/month for up to 100 account connections, with $2.50 per additional account per month
• Elite: Starting at $850/month for up to 100 account connections, with $4.00 per additional account per month
Ease of Use: CircleBlack emphasizes a modern and intuitive user interface for both advisors and clients. The platform is designed to be user-friendly, with a focus on streamlining workflows and providing easy access to client information.
Selecting the optimal portfolio reporting tool requires careful consideration of your firm's size, client base, investment strategies, and budget. There is no one-size-fits-all solution. Smaller RIAs with simpler portfolios may find a more streamlined, cost-effective platform to be sufficient, while larger firms with complex client needs may require the robust capabilities of an Addepar or a Black Diamond.
Considerations:
• Firm Size and AUM: Smaller firms may prioritize affordability and ease of use, while larger firms may need more advanced features.
• Client Complexity: The types of assets and investment strategies used will influence the reporting capabilities required.
• Integration Needs: Consider how well the platform integrates with your existing payments processing, CRM, financial planning software, and other tools.
• Budget: Portfolio reporting tools vary significantly in price, so it's essential to find a solution that fits your budget.
• Long-Term Vision: Think about how your firm's needs may evolve in the future and choose a platform that can grow with you.
The Importance of Implementation and Training
Regardless of the platform you choose, proper implementation and training are crucial for maximizing its value. Invest time in configuring the system correctly, training your staff, and developing standardized reporting processes.
For more of our thought leadership, check us out here at www.atomicinsights.io/company/blog